Quick Guide for Leaders

Purpose of Peer Review and Enhancement (PRE) 

PRE is a developmental, reflective, and peer-supported process aimed at enhancing academic practice. It includes peer dialogue, support, observation, and action planning, and should be connected into other institutional processes like Performance Development Reviewing (PDRs), Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL), and course development plans (CDPs).

Core Expectations

  • All staff with student-facing roles must engage in PRE annually.
  • PRE includes peer observation of teaching (POT) as an element which may be required (School/Instittute and/or PSRB determined).
  • PRE is owned by the individual, supported by peers acting as critical friends.
  • PRE outcomes should be discussed at appraisal (PDR) and inform future development.
  • PRE should be simple, efficient, and aligned with existing processes (e.g., module review, CPD, curriculum design).
  • PRE should lead to dissemination of good practice and support professional recognition.

Key Updates and Priorities

In 2025, we undertook a review of PRE and determined the following updates and priorities:

1. Reframe PRE as Developmental, Not Compliance:

  • Shift perception from “tick-box” to holistic enhancement. 
  • Use case studies and positive framing to illustrate impact. 
  • Consider extending the PRE cycle to 24 months for deeper reflection and ongoing development.

2. Integrate PRE into Institutional Processes

  • Align with PDR, Academic Careers Framework, TEF, SoTL, student feedback, and quality enhancement.
  • Ensure apprenticeship provision is included and observation (also known as learning visits) is included.

3. Promote Cross-Disciplinary & Inclusive Practice

  • Encourage pairings across disciplines and grades. Explore cross School/Institute and/or College pairings.
  • Use PRE to foster collaborative learning communities in your School/Institute.

4. Build a Supportive Feedback Culture

  • Provide support for feedback and reflective practice.
  • Celebrate and share good practice.

5. Ensure Structured Follow-Up Use skills matrices to identify development needs.

  • Follow up with School/Institute sharing and individually in PDR conversations.
  • Collect themes and key learning to inform college and university priorities.

6. Make PRE Outcomes Visible and Actionable

  • Link PRE to SoTL projects, internal conferences, and module/course review and development.
  • Encourage dissemination via blogs, case studies, and presentations.

Leadership Actions

Determine your School/Institute approach for the academic year: Agree the areas of focus, the approach to facilitating pairing, the role of POT, and set-up a method of collecting outcomes. Discuss the approach with your College ADLTSS.

Communicate clearly: Ensure staff understand PRE is developmental, supportive, and includes more than just POT.
Support pairings: Facilitate cross-college and cross-discipline collaborations.
Embed in strategy: Align PRE with school/institute priorities and CPD planning.
Monitor and follow up: Ensure outcomes are collected, discussed at PDRs, course team meetings, and inform future planning.
Celebrate and share: Promote dissemination of PRE outcomes and good practice within your school/insititute, College, and wider.

Awareness Gaps for Leaders to Address

  • Conflation of the full PRE process with the element of Peer Observation of Teaching (POT).  POT can be an element of PRE. PRE is much broader than POT.
  • Lack of follow-up and impact tracking.
  • Inconsistent implementation within schools and institutes.
  • Limited visibility and/or valuing of outcomes within schools and institutes.

Get Support:

Contact your local School/Institute learning, teaching and assessment lead for support and guidance on the approach your area is taking.